New York City’s Oldest Operating Whiskey Distillery

Originally published in 2016. Updated in 2024 as we prepare to feature Kings County Distillery’s Bourbon in our February Bourbon & Chocolate SipScout Kit. Grab yours or join SipScout as a member today!

Sometimes you just get lucky. You’re out of town, staying in a hotel, have a few hours to kill and want to nourish your passion for all things epicurean by finding something off the beaten path to explore and learn about. A short 15 minute walk later and you find yourself in the Brooklyn Navy Yard in front of a 117 year old Paymaster Building which now houses the oldest operating whiskey distillery in New York City since Prohibition, Kings County Distillery. All of this merely steps away from where the prohibition era Brooklyn Whiskey Wars took place with many illegal Irish distillers fighting back, jumping out of windows to evade arrest and more. As soon as you walk through the doors and up the stairs you can feel the history… it honestly almost feels like a sacred whiskey site once I took some time to tour their “Boozeum” and learn all about this era and some of the historical happenings all around where I was standing…

Kings County Distillery Boozeum items in a collage

If all of that wasn’t enough, I quickly learned that this lucky find was also named the 2016 Distillery of the Year by the American Distilling Institute. Needless to say I was pretty excited for my very own private tour (luck strikes again!) with the incredible Executive Bourbon Steward, Lia Niskanen, and I’m excited to bring you along with me on this photo journey.

First we head downstairs to see where all of the magic begins once they have their choice grains delivered, many of which come from an organic farm in the local Finger Lakes region. All 40 thousand gallons of whiskey made each year by Kings County Distillery are fermented, distilled, aged and bottled in this very location, It is a beautiful 19th century building…and at 5pm the light streaming through the windows and hitting the brick walls made for an even more unforgettable experience.

So first up is the mashing phase in which the grain grist and water is mixed in what is almost like a giant stock pot and heated up to turn the starch into fermentable sugars. Then the liquid is strained off from the grains…this liquid is often called wort…and while the larger scale distillers often move both the wort and the grain into the next fermentation stage together, Kings County is an off-grain distiller. This means that the grain is only used in this first mashing step. After that the grain is distributed back to local farms for composting and animal feed and only the wort is moved forward into the next stage.

Fermentation bubbling away at Kings County Distillery

And lucky for me, that next stage of fermentation had some rye bubbling and fermenting away right before my very eyes. With a nice touch of Americana as a backdrop, I might add! In this stage yeast is added to the wort, causing the sugars to ferment and turn into alcohol. The smell down here is amazing…almost bread-like but with a distinct undertone that lets you know something even more delicious is happening.

KIngs County Distillery still with American Flag and open fermenters in the background

Next, we move a few steps over to the distilling phase. The small size of this operation now helps me see that they truly are actively making whiskey 365 days a year…pretty impressive. This, I have to say is my favorite stage, simply because I’m a sucker for old-world ways with beautiful, almost antique looking equipment. Colin Spoleman, their master distiller who was born and raised in Kentucky but actually didn’t start making moonshine until he moved to New York after college, prefers the Scottish Alembic Pot Stills that you see above.

So first, there is a stripping still where the most toxic alcohols are “stripped” out of the liquid as it vaporizes (or turns into a spirit), moves up a connected pipe, is quickly cooled and then turned back into a liquid where it lands in the spirit still right next to it. Kings County Distillery does a double distillation and works its way through the four fractions of the whiskey (foreshot, head, heart, tail) completely manually. No automated technology here! That means they are constantly keeping an eye on the speed that the spirit is coming out of the spirit still (one sign of which phase it’s in), checking the proof with a hydrometer (another sign), and ultimately tasting it to determine when to start and stop collecting for that particular batch of whiskey or bourbon depending on what Colin is looking to create. This whole step in the process is really fascinating and what finally comes out here is still-proof…next we move it to the barrel-proof stage! 

A barrel from Jan 2014 aging away at Kings County Distillery

Ah, the barrel room…it was just gorgeous as you can see in the key picture of this post. The brick walls, the sunlight streaming in, the rows and rows upon barrels, the angels’ share in the air. I’m in my happy place. Kings County specializes in bourbon, which means they go through a lot of barrels since you can only put bourbon in an unused barrel. They also make interesting whiskies like this oat whiskey pictured here. And even with their bourbon, they are unique. Most bourbons are either corn/wheat or corn/rye mixtures but Colin’s flagship bourbon is a more rare corn/malted barley mixture…and let me tell you it’s deliciously creamy and almost buttery.

I learned something new and fascinating in the barrel room…something likely very well known to super whiskey connoisseurs. I’ve been immersed in wine country for so long, so while I’m very familiar with the barrel aging process in wine I’m less familiar when it comes to whiskey and just assumed it was pretty much the same. While a lot of it is, there was one big difference…the fact that there is intentionally no temperature regulation in the whiskey aging rooms. In fact, they want extreme lows of the winter and highs of the summer because as temperature fluctuates the wood in the barrel expands and constricts allowing more of the whiskey into the wood and then pushing it back out. Which imparts much more of the flavor of the wood into the spirit itself. Whereas wine is looking for a much more subtle kiss of the flavors of the wood and so therefore regulates the temperature. Fascinating!

Sampler Pack of Kings County Distillery Whiskeys

Last, but certainly not least, we head back to the tasting room where we started…the three whiskies above are their most popular, flagship whiskies that are available most broadly. As I mentioned previously their bourbon is really incredible and a bit unique in the creamy texture. The moonshine I love as well…partially because he’s calling it moonshine and resisting the trend to call it a white whiskey or something else like that. I asked a little about that and Lia told me that Colin feels passionately about elevating the reputation of moonshine, which in reality is just un-aged whiskey and where Colin started his distilling career. I honestly wasn’t expecting to like the chocolate whiskey…I tend to be pretty biased about flavor infused spirits and beers…but this was incredible and could honestly replace a port for me. They use a super dark, almost salty smelling chocolate from Mast Brothers Chocolatier, who’s head office and factory is right next door in the Navy Yards as well…it’s just so Brooklyn, I love it. I never thought I’d be into this but I’m definitely buying a bottle to have on hand for after dinner drinks!

Kings County Distillery Award Winning Whiskeys all lined up on a shelf together with their medals

Next time you’re in Brooklyn make sure to check Kings County Distillery out…highly educational and fun tour with a great tasting at the end. Beyond that…look at all of those awards! Truly amazing whiskies and bourbons with some fun, unique seasonal ones as well. When you’re done with your tour make sure to head over to The Gatehouses on your way out of Navy Yard to taste even more of their award winning whiskies and sample some fantastic, artisan cocktails as well. My favorite was the Harlan Nog, which included their oat whiskey, a honeyshine and frothed egg whites…but don’t take my word for it, get out to Brooklyn and go try some yourself!

When we discover favorite new distilleries we’re always considering them for new and exciting ways to support them and help you support them as well. Now, eight years after this first visit back in 2016 we have some exciting news!  As we finally launched our SipScout Craft Alcohol Membership Club you have an opportunity to try Kings County for yourself – no matter if you’re in New York City or not! And, distiller Colin Spoelman will be joining us for our February 15th, 2024 Bourbon and Chocolate tasting alongside many of the other 5 craft distillers featured in that month’s kit. Make sure to order by January 31, 2024 to get in on the fun!  

Bottles of craft beer, wine, and spirits

Are You A Craft Drink Explorer?

Do you want access to exclusive, hard to find, or lesser known craft alcohol like those we featured here?

Then you, my friend…are in the right place! Join the first and only rotating craft alcohol membership club to get each kit that goes along with our monthly SipScout party and join in on the fun!

Join SipScout or Get A Single Kit

Missed this kit? Join as a monthly member and try other great craft brands from all different boozy categories each month from the comfort of your own home. Or simply keep an eye on upcoming themes and grab a particular kit you’re interested (just make sure to do so during the prior month when it’s on sale). Drop a comment below on who you’d liketo see featured in an upcoming kit and we’ll do our best to make it happen!

Join the conversation!

1 Comment

  1. fitspresso reviews

    I eagerly started following this amazing site a couple days ago, they have useful content for subscribers. The site owner works hard to inform fans. I’m delighted and hope they continue providing excellent info.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Whiskey tasting glass icon

Download our free tasting guide

Learn how to taste like a pro no matter what you're sipping on. Join Tippler Nation and get your free download now.

 

Categories

Related articles

Aquavit bottle
What is Aquavit?

What is Aquavit?

What is aquavit? We take deep dive into the history of the spirit of Scandinavia, how it's made, and how to use aquavit in one of our favorite cocktails, perfect for Easter Brunch!

Keep Exploring The Craft

Attend an Event

Make a Cocktail

Attend an Event

Get notified about in-person events

Thanks, we'll let you know when we have upcoming in-person events!

Become a SipScout Member and Save $20 on Your First Kit!

Join our mailing list to receive your discount and get the latest boozy news from our team.

You have successfully subscribed. Use code DrinksExplorer to save $20 on the first kit of a new membership at thecraftycask.com/shop/sipscout This code does not apply to gifts or one-time kit purchases.